Pizza Plus (Shelton Ave) Online Ordering Menu

Shelton Avenue
New Haven, CT 06513

11:00 AM - Midnight

90% of 21 customers recommended

Start your delivery order.

Check Availability

ITALIAN SPECIALTIES

Grilled Chicken with Garlic & Oil

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli with Garlic & Oil

Chicken Francese

Breaded chicken breast with lemon butter sauce.

Chicken Marsala

Breaded chicken breast and mushrooms in a brown marsala wine sauce.

Chicken Alfredo

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo

Chicken Primavera

With onions, mushrooms, peppers, and spinach.

Chicken Carbonara

With sausage, bacon, and ham in white cream sauce.

Chicken Alla Vodka

Chicken Broccoli Alla Vodka

Baked Ziti with Ricotta Cheese

Baked Ziti with Chicken

Baked Ziti with Meatball

Baked Ziti with Sausage

Baked Ziti with Sausage & Meatball

Chicken Parmigiana

Shrimp Parmigiana

Eggplant Parmigiana

Meatball Parmigiana

Sausage Parmigiana

Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana

Chicken & Eggplant Parmigiana

Chicken, Sausage, & Meatball Parmigiana

VALUE COMBOS

#1 Cheese Pizza, 10 Wings & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#2 Cheese Calzone, 10 Wings & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#3 Party Size Cheese Pizza, 20 Wings & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#4 (2) Cheese Pizzas

Additional toppings cost extra.

#5 (2) Party Size Cheese Pizzas

Additional toppings cost extra.

#6 (2) Cheese Pizzas, 15 Wings & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#7 2-Topping Pizza & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#8 Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda

Additional toppings cost extra.

#9 Party Size 1-Topping Pizza & 2-Liter

Additional toppings cost extra.

#10 Small Cheese Pizza, 6 Wings & 20 oz. Soda

Additional toppings cost extra.

#11 Small 2-Topping Pizza & Can Soda

Additional toppings cost extra.

#12 (2) Medium Cheese Pizzas, 10 Buffalo Wings & 2-Liter Soda

Additional toppings cost extra.

#13 Any Large Grinder with Fries & Can Soda

#14 Half Tray Penne Alfredo

#14 Half Tray Penne Alla Vodka

#14 Half Tray Penne Francese

#14 Half Tray Penne Marsala

NY STYLE PIZZA

Fresh homemade dough made daily. Topped with our delicious pizza sauce and with the highest quality cheese and freshest pizza toppings.

Create Your Own Pizza

GOURMET PIZZA

Pizza Plus Special Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, mushroom, onion & peppers.

Meat Lover Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon & ham.

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham & jalapeno.

Broccoli, eggplant, black olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach.

Baby shrimp, parsley & garlic.

Fresh clams, bacon & fresh garlic.

Peppers, onions, black olives & feta cheese.

Ham & pineapple.

Margherita Pizza

Fresh tomato, basil, & garlic.

Philly Steak Pizza

Steak meat, mushrooms, onions & pepper.

Five Cheese Pizza (Red or White)

Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, ricotta & grated romano cheese.

Mediterranean Pizza (Red or White)

Ricotta cheese, feta cheese, spinach & eggplant.

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Crispy chicken & bacon tossed in ranch dressing over lettuce, tomatoes, red onions & black olives.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

BBQ Chicken Pizza

APPETIZERS

Topped w/ Chili & Cheese

Pizza Plus Fries (Enough for 2)

French fries topped with bacon, steak & mozzarella cheese.

Steak Fries (Enough for 2)

French fries topped with steak & mozzarella cheese.

Mega Fries (Enough for 2)

French fries topped with bacon & mozzarella cheese.

Mozzarella Sticks

Jalapeño Peppers

Chicken Tenders

Buffalo Tenders

WINGS

Traditional or boneless. Our signature Buffalo wings are hand tossed in your favorite Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing.

Traditional Wings

PLATTERS

All platters served with French Fries.

Buffalo Wings (8)

Boneless Wings (8)

Fried Shrimp (8)

Mozzarella Sticks (8)

Jalapeno Poppers (8)

Chicken Tenders (4)

Buffalo Chicken Tenders (4)

With bleu cheese.

Flounder Fillets (4)

SOUPS

Served with bread.

Chicken & Meatball

New England Clam Chowder

Italian Wedding

SALADS

All salads include romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onions & tomatoes unless noted. *Nothing will be put on the side except dressing.*

Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken

Garden salad topped with grilled chicken.

Garden Salad with Baby Shrimp

Garden salad topped with baby shrimp.

With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons.

Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken

With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, chicken & croutons.

With grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg.

With turkey, ham, provolone cheese, hard boiled egg.

Antipasto Salad

Fresh garden salad with sliced Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni and provolone cheese.

With romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta cheese & black olives.

Southwestern Salad

With romaine lettuce, croutons, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spicy chicken.

CALZONES

All served with 8oz marinara sauce.

Create Your Own Calzone

served with 8oz

With sausage, meatball, pepperoni and ham.

With eggplant, spinach, olives and pepper.

With Feta cheese, onions, & olives.

Chicken, Eggplant Parm

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, and jalapenos.

STUFFED BREAD / ROLLS

12" made fresh to order from fresh dough and served with 8oz marinara sauce

Buffalo Chicken

served with bleu cheese on the side

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Broccoli & Sausage

Chicken, Broccoli & Spinach

With onions, peppers & broccoli.

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon

COLD GRINDERS

All cold grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

served with lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese

served with lettuce, tomato, mayo

served with lettuce,tomato,mayo and american cheese

served with lettuce,tomato,mayo and american cheese

served with salami,ham,pepperoni,american cheese,lettuce,tomato,mayo

HOT GRINDERS

All hot grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

Steak & Cheese Grinder

With lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, & American cheese.

Philly Steak & Cheese Grinder

Mushrooms, onions, peppers & American cheese.

Hamburger Grinder

Cheeseburger Grinder

Bacon Cheeseburger Grinder

Crispy Chicken Grinder

Grilled Chicken Melt Grinder

Chicken Bacon Ranch Grinder Sub

PARMIGIANA GRINDERS

all parmigiana grinders come with marinara sauce and mozzarella chese

Sausage & Pepper Sub

Sausage & Meatball Sub

Chicken & Eggplant Sub

BURGERS

6oz burger served with lettuce, tomato & mayo.

Bacon Cheeseburger

Grilled Chicken

QUESADILLAS & WRAPS

All quesadillas and wraps served with fries. Quesadillas are served with ranch dressing on the side.

Grilled Chicken

With lettuce, tomato, onion & cheese.

Grilled Chicken Caesar

With romaine, lettuce, tomato, Ceasar Dressing & cheese.

Buffalo Chicken

With lettuce, tomato, cheese.

With lettuce, tomato, & cheese.

With onion, mushrooms, peppers & cheese.

BREADS

8 pieces each. Served with 8oz marinara sauce.

Garlic Cheese Sticks

SEAFOOD

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair.

Jumbo Shrimp Francese

Jumbo shrimp sauteed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Marinara

Jumbo shrimp over marinara sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

Jumbo shrimp sauteed with a lemon white wine sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Jumbo shrimp over spicy marinara sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Alla Supremo

Jumbo shrimp & clams sauteed in a light marinara sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Florentine

Jumbo shrimp, spinach & tomatoes sauteed in a white wine sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Florio

Jumbo shrimp, mushrooms, peas & spinach sauteed with garlic & oil.

Clams Alla Supremo

Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy white sauce.

Clam Sauce (Red)

Clam Sauce (White)

SIDES

Grilled Chicken (1 Piece)

Breaded Chicken (1 Piece)

Served with marinara sauce.

Served with marinara sauce.

Sauteed Spinach

Sauteed with garlic and oil.

Sauteed Vegetables

Sauteed with garlic and oil.

DESSERTS

Ice cream dessert.

SMOOTHIES

Strawberry Banana

Pineapple Banana

Tropical Rainbow

ICE CREAM

Cookies N Cream

MILKSHAKES

Vanilla Milkshake

Chocolate Milkshake

Strawberry Milkshake

Strawberry & Banana Milkshake

Cookies N Cream.

COLD BEVERAGES

Poland Spring Water

Canned Drink (12 oz.)

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Iced Tea.

Bottled Soda (20 oz.)

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Pineapple Soda, Grape Soda.

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Grape Soda, Fruit Punch, Iced Tea.

Red Bull (8.4 oz.)

Monster Energy Drink

Homemade Iced Tea (24 oz.)

Homemade Lemonade (24 oz.)

Your cart is empty.

Accepts Google Pay

Accepts Venmo