Expand Menu
VALUE COMBOS
Value Combo #1
1 cheese pizza, 10 wings and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Value Combo #2
1 gourmet pizza, 10 wings and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Value Combo #3
1 party size cheese pizza, 20 wings and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$31.95
Value Combo #4
2 cheese pizzas. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Value Combo #5
2 gourmet pizzas. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Value Combo #6
2 party cheese pizzas. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$32.95
Value Combo #7
1 large 3-topping pizza and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$18.95
Value Combo #8
1 large cheese pizza and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$12.95
Value Combo #9
1 party size cheese pizza with 1 regular topping and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$23.95
Value Combo #10
1 small cheese pizza, 6 wings & a 20 ounce soda. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$14.95
Value Combo #11
1 large pizza with 2 regular toppings, 10 Buffalo wings and a 2 liter. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$23.95
Value Combo #12
1 small pizza with 2 regular toppings and a can of soda. Additional toppings cost extra.
Click To Order
$10.95
Value Combo #13
1 large cheese pizza, 2 pints of ice cream or Italian ice and a 2 liter.
Click To Order
$21.95
Value Combo #14
1 large cheese pizza, 15 Buffalo wings and a 2 liter.
Click To Order
$23.50
APPETIZERS
Tex-Mex Fries
Topped w/ Chili & Cheese
Click To Order
$9.95
Pizza Plus Fries (Enough for 2)
French fries topped with bacon, steak & mozzarella cheese.
Click To Order
$8.95
Steak Fries (Enough for 2)
French fries topped with steak & mozzarella cheese.
Click To Order
$7.95
Mega Fries (Enough for 2)
French fries topped with bacon & mozzarella cheese.
Click To Order
$7.95
French Fries
Click To Order
Click For Price
Onion Rings
Click To Order
Click For Price
Fried Calamari
Click To Order
$9.95
Fried Shrimp
Click To Order
Click For Price
Fried Ravioli
Click To Order
Click For Price
Mozzarella Sticks
Click To Order
Click For Price
Jalapeño Peppers
Click To Order
Click For Price
Chicken Fingers
Click To Order
Click For Price
Buffalo Chicken Fingers
Click To Order
Click For Price
Fried Scallops
Click To Order
Click For Price
Clam Strips
Click To Order
Click For Price
WINGS
Traditional or boneless. Our signature Buffalo wings are hand tossed in your favorite Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing.
SOUPS
SALADS
All salads include romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onions & tomatoes unless noted.
Garden Salad
Click To Order
Click For Price
Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
Garden salad topped with grilled chicken.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Garden Salad with Tuna Salad
Garden salad topped with tuna.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Garden Salad with Shrimp Salad
Garden salad topped with baby shrimp.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Garden Salad with Avocado
Garden salad topped with avocado.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Caesar Salad
With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, chicken & croutons.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Cobb Salad
With grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Chef Salad
With turkey, ham, provolone cheese, hard boiled egg.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Antipasto Salad
Fresh garden salad with sliced Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni and provolone cheese.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Greek Salad
With romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta cheese & black olives.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Southwestern Salad
With romaine lettuce, croutons, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spicy chicken.
Click To Order
Click For Price
NY STYLE OR PAN PIZZA
Fresh homemade dough made daily. Topped with our delicious pizza sauce and with the highest quality cheese and freshest pizza toppings.
GOURMET PIZZA
Pizza Plus Special Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, mushroom, onion & peppers.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon & ham.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Veggie Lover
Broccoli, eggplant, black olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Philly Steak Pizza
Steak meat, mushrooms, onions & pepper.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham & pineapple.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Shrimp Casino
Baby shrimp, parsley & garlic.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Clam Casino
Fresh clams, bacon & fresh garlic.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Five Cheese Pizza (Red or White)
Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, ricotta & grated romano cheese.
Click To Order
Click For Price
California Pizza
Ham, pineapple, eggplant, spinach, black olives & onions.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Mexican Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham & jalapeno.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Greek Pizza
Peppers, onions, black olives & feta cheese.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Mediterranean Pizza (Red or White)
Ricotta cheese, feta cheese, spinach & eggplant.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Click To Order
Click For Price
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Click To Order
Click For Price
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Pizza
Click To Order
Click For Price
Taco Pizza
Homemade salsa, jalapeno peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, ground meat & cheddar cheese.
Click To Order
$20.95
Baked Ziti Pizza
Click To Order
$20.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Crispy chicken & bacon tossed in ranch dressing over lettuce, tomatoes, red onions & black olives.
Click To Order
$20.95
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Click To Order
$20.95
Chicken Bacon Avocado Pizza
Click To Order
$20.95
CALZONES
Create Your Own Calzone
Click To Order
$7.95
Meat Lover's
With sausage, meatball, pepperoni and ham.
Click To Order
$10.95
Veggie Lover's
With eggplant, spinach, olives and pepper.
Click To Order
$10.50
Cheese Lover's
With feta cheese, provolone and grated cheese.
Click To Order
$9.95
Southwestern
Chicken cutlet with jalapenos and marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$9.95
Eggplant Lover's
Click To Order
$9.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Click To Order
$10.95
COLD GRINDERS
All cold grinders served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & provolone cheese.
HOT GRINDERS
All hot grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.
Steak & Cheese
Click To Order
$7.95
Philly Steak & Cheese
Mushrooms, onions, peppers & American cheese.
Click To Order
$7.95
Hamburger
Click To Order
$7.95
Cheeseburger
Click To Order
$8.50
Bacon Cheeseburger
Click To Order
$8.95
Crispy Chicken
Click To Order
$7.95
Grilled Chicken Melt
Click To Order
$7.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Click To Order
$8.50
PARMIGIANA GRINDERS
BURGERS
1/2 lb burger served with lettuce, tomato & mayo.
WRAPS
Crispy Chicken
With lettuce and ranch.
Click To Order
$4.95
Grilled Chicken
With lettuce and honey mustard.
Click To Order
$4.95
Filet of Fish
With lettuce and tartar sauce.
Click To Order
$4.95
Turkey
With lettuce and mayo.
Click To Order
$4.95
Ham
With lettuce and mayo.
Click To Order
$4.95
Salami
With lettuce and mayo.
Click To Order
$4.95
STUFFED BREAD/ROLLS
12" made fresh to order from fresh dough.
BREADS
8 pieces each. Served with sauce.
BAKED PASTAS
Served with bread.
Tour of Italy
Combination of chicken parmigiana, sausage parmigiana and meatball parmigiana.
Click To Order
$13.95
Pizza Plus Special
Stuffed shells, ravioli, meatballs and baked ziti, baked parmigiana style.
Click To Order
$12.95
Stuffed Shells
Click To Order
$8.95
Baked Ziti
Click To Order
$9.50
Baked Ziti with Ricotta Cheese
Click To Order
$10.50
Baked Ziti & Halal Meatballs
Click To Order
$12.75
Baked Ziti & Meatballs
Click To Order
$12.50
Baked Ziti & Sausage
Click To Order
$12.50
Baked Ziti & Chicken
Click To Order
$12.95
Baked Ziti Sicilian
Penne pasta with chopped eggplant in marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$10.95
PASTA DINNERS
Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti.
With Meatballs (8 oz.)
Click To Order
$9.50
With Halal Meatballs (8 oz.)
Click To Order
$9.95
With Sausage (10 oz.)
Click To Order
$9.50
With Sausage & Meatballs
Click To Order
$9.95
Alfredo Sauce
Click To Order
Click For Price
Alla Vodka Sauce
Click To Order
Click For Price
Clam Sauce
Red or white.
Click To Order
Click For Price
Bolognese
Traditional meat sauce with a touch of cream.
Click To Order
$12.95
Ham, Mushrooms, & Peas
Sautéed in a pink cream sauce
Click To Order
$10.95
Broccoli & Sausage
Sautéed in a light marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$11.50
Ham, Bacon, & Onions
Sautéed in a white cream sauce.
Click To Order
$12.50
CHICKEN SPECIALTIES
Chicken & Spinach
Sauteed in a white wine sauce.
Click To Order
$11.95
Chicken, Mushrooms, & Peas with Marinara Sauce
Sautéed in a light marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$11.95
Chicken, Mushrooms, & Peas with Pink Sauce
Sautéed in a pink cream sauce
Click To Order
$12.50
Chicken, Sausage, & Broccoli
Sautéed with tomatoes in a sherry wine sauce.
Click To Order
$12.50
Chicken & Broccoli
Sautéed in a garlic and oil sauce.
Click To Order
$11.95
Chicken, Sausage, & Mushroom
Sautéed in a sherry wine sauce.
Click To Order
$12.50
SEAFOOD
Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti.
Shrimp Marinara
Sautéed jumbo shrimp with marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$14.50
Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo shrimp sautéed with garlic, oil & parsley in a lemon white wine sauce.
Click To Order
$14.95
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Jumbo shrimp sautéed with spicy marinara sauce.
Click To Order
$14.95
Shrimp Alla Supremo
Baby shrimp & clams sautéed in a light marina sauce.
Click To Order
$12.95
Shrimp Florio
Baby shrimp sautéed with mushrooms, peas and spinach in a virgin olive oil and garlic.
Click To Order
$12.95
Clams Alla Supremo
Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy white sauce.
Click To Order
$12.95
CLASSIC DINNERS
Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti. Substitute pasta with roasted red peppers. Platters are not served with pasta.
Chicken Francese
Chicken breast dipped in egg and sautéed in a lemon white wine sauce.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Picatta
Chicken breast and capers sautéed in lemon white wine sauce.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Marsala
Chicken breast sautéed with mushrooms in a brown marsala wine sauce.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Florentine
Grilled chicken sautéed with spinach, garlic broccoli & provolone cheese.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Pizzaiola
Grilled chicken topped with sautéed onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli & provolone cheese.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken topped with ham, bleu cheese sauce & provolone cheese.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken with Eggplant
Grilled chicken topped with sautéed spinach, garlic, teriyaki sauce, eggplant & provolone cheese.
Click To Order
$12.95
Chicken Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Chicken & Eggplant Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Eggplant Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Meatball Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Halal Meatball Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Sausage Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana
Click To Order
Click For Price
FRIED DOUGH
SIDES
DESSERTS
SMOOTHIES
Avocado
Click To Order
Click For Price
Avocado & Spinach
Click To Order
Click For Price
Cucumber & Greek Yogurt
Click To Order
Click For Price
Avocado, Broccoli, & Spinach
Click To Order
Click For Price
Tropical Rainbow
Click To Order
Click For Price
Strawberry Bomb
Click To Order
Click For Price
Strawberry Banana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Pineapple Banana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Pineapple
Click To Order
Click For Price
Mango
Click To Order
Click For Price
ICE CREAM
ITALIAN ICE
MILKSHAKES
Avocado
Click To Order
Click For Price
Vanilla
Click To Order
Click For Price
Chocolate
Click To Order
Click For Price
Strawberry
Click To Order
Click For Price
Strawberry Banana
Click To Order
Click For Price
Root Beer Float
Click To Order
Click For Price
Coca Cola Float
Click To Order
Click For Price
COLD BEVERAGES
2-Liter
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Grape Soda, Fruit Punch, Iced Tea.
Click To Order
$3.00
Bottled Soda (20 oz.)
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Pineapple Soda, Grape Soda.
Click To Order
$2.25
Canned Drink (12 oz.)
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Iced Tea.
Click To Order
$1.25
Homemade Iced Tea (24 oz.)
Click To Order
$1.75
Citrus Punch (24 oz.)
Click To Order
$2.00
Mango Punch (24 oz.)
Click To Order
$2.00
Snapple
Lemon, Peach, Mango, Fruit Punch, Kiwi Strawberry.
Click To Order
$2.25
Gatorade
Lemon Lime, Orange, Fruit Punch.
Click To Order
$2.25
Monster Energy Drink
Click To Order
$2.95
Red Bull (8.4 oz.)
Click To Order
$2.95
Bottled Water
Click To Order
$1.25
DAILY LUNCH DEALS
Available Mon - Fri from 11:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m. Served with 24 oz. homemade fruit punch or iced tea.
Premium Chicken Tenders (4) with French Fries
Click To Order
$7.98
Buffalo Chicken Tenders (4) with French Fries
Click To Order
$8.45
Eggplant Parmigiana with Penne Pasta
Click To Order
$9.40
Buffalo Wings (8) with French Fries
Click To Order
$9.40
Small 2-Topping Pizza
Regular toppings only.
Click To Order
$9.40
Any Cold Cut Grinder with French Fries
Each grinder comes with lettuce, tomato, mayo, & American cheese.
Click To Order
$8.45
Any Wrap with French Fries
Each wrap comes with lettuce, tomato, mayo, & American cheese.
Click To Order
$7.98
Any Hot Grinder with French Fries
Each grinder comes with lettuce, tomato, mayo, & American cheese (except Philly). The Philly, & Steak & Cheese sandwich comes with grilled onions, mushrooms, peppers, & American cheese.
Click To Order
$9.40
Pizza Plus (Shelton Ave)
Come to Pizza Plus in New Haven, Connecticut for delicious pizza, wings, salads, and more! Try one of our calzones such as the Southwestern, Chicken Bacon Ranch, or the Meat Lover's! Our menu also offers burgers, wraps, pastas, and desserts! We are located on Shelton Avenue between Huntington Street and Bassett Street. Albertus Magnus College and Beaver Pond Park aren't too far from us! Order online for carryout or delivery!Hours of Business
Sunday
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Su 12:00-22:00
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Mo,Tu,We,Th 11:00-23:00
Friday and Saturday
11:00 AM - Midnight
Fr,Sa 11:00-23:59
Share on:
Pizza,Calzones,Wings,Pasta,Dessert,Seafood,Wraps,Hamburgers,Salads,Sandwiches,Chicken,Fast Casual,Smoothies and Juices,Soup