0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Locations
Pizza Plus Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Locations
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Pizza Plus (Shelton Ave) Online Ordering Menu

328 Shelton Ave.
New Haven, CT 06511
(203) 752-1800
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
90% of 21 customers recommended
Start your delivery order.
Check Availability

VALUE COMBOS

# 1 - 1 Cheese Pizza, 10 Wings & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$23.75+
# 2 - 1 Cheese Calzone, 10 Wings & 2-LiterSoda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$20.25+
# 3 - 1 Party Size Cheese Pizza, 20 Wings & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$39.75+
# 4 - 2 Cheese Pizzas 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$25.09+
# 5 - 2 Party Size Cheese Pizzas 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$38.75+
# 6 - 2 Cheese Pizzas, 15 Wings & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$38.89+
# 7 - 1 Two Topping Pizza & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$18.69+
# 8 - 1 Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$14.45+
# 9 - Party Size 1-Topping Pizza & 2-Liter Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$26.55+
# 10 - Small Cheese Pizza, 6 Wings & 20 Oz. Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$16.07+
# 11 - Small 2-Topping Pizza & Can Soda 
Additional toppings cost extra.
$12.11+

NY STYLE PIZZA

Fresh homemade dough made daily. Topped with our delicious pizza sauce and with the highest quality cheese and freshest pizza toppings.
Create Your Own Pizza 
$10.95+

GOURMET PIZZA

Pizza Plus Special Pizza 
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, mushroom, onion & peppers.
$14.00+
Meat Lover Pizza 
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon & ham.
$14.00+
Veggie Lover 
Broccoli, eggplant, black olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach.
$14.50+
Philly Steak Pizza 
Steak meat, mushrooms, onions & pepper.
$15.00+
Hawaiian Pizza 
Ham & pineapple.
$13.00+
Shrimp Casino 
Baby shrimp, parsley & garlic.
$15.50+
Clam Casino 
Fresh clams, bacon & fresh garlic.
$14.50+
Five Cheese Pizza (Red or White) 
Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, ricotta & grated romano cheese.
$15.50+
Mexican Pizza 
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham & jalapeno.
$14.25+
Greek Pizza 
Peppers, onions, black olives & feta cheese.
$13.75+
Mediterranean Pizza (Red or White) 
Ricotta cheese, feta cheese, spinach & eggplant.
$14.75+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza 
$13.75+
BBQ Chicken Pizza 
$13.75+
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Pizza 
$14.50+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza 
Crispy chicken, bacon and ranch dressing
$15.50+
Margherita Pizza 
Fresh tomato, basil, & garlic.
$13.00+

APPETIZERS

Tex-Mex Fries 
Topped w/ Chili & Cheese
$12.50+
Pizza Plus Fries (Enough for 2) 
French fries topped with bacon, steak & mozzarella cheese.
$12.50+
Steak Fries (Enough for 2) 
French fries topped with steak & mozzarella cheese.
$12.00+
Mega Fries (Enough for 2) 
French fries topped with bacon & mozzarella cheese.
$12.00+
French Fries 
$4.75+
Onion Rings 
$6.00+
Fried Calamari 
$12.50+
Fried Shrimp 
$6.95+
Fried Ravioli 
$6.50+
Mozzarella Sticks 
$6.50+
Jalapeño Peppers 
$6.50+
Chicken Tenders 
$9.00+
Buffalo Tenders 
$9.75+
Curly Fries 
$5.50+

WINGS

Traditional or boneless. Our signature Buffalo wings are hand tossed in your favorite Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing.
Traditional Wings 
$8.00+
Boneless Wings 
$8.00+

PLATTERS

All platters served with French Fries.
Buffalo Wings (8) 
$12.75+
Boneless Wings (8) 
$15.00+
Fried Shrimp (8) 
$11.95
Buffalo Chicken Tenders (4) 
With bleu cheese.
$9.75
Wings (6), Chicken Tenders (2) 
$12.75+
Mozzarella Sticks (8) 
$10.95
Chicken Tenders (4) 
$9.00

SOUPS

Chicken Noodle 
$6.95+
Chicken & Meatball 
$6.95+
New England Clam Chowder 
$6.95+
Chili 
$6.95+
Italian Wedding 
$6.95+

SALADS

All salads include romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onions & tomatoes unless noted. *Nothing will be put on the side except dressing.*
Garden Salad  
$10.00+
Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken 
Garden salad topped with grilled chicken.
$13.00+
Garden Salad with Tuna  
Garden salad topped with tuna.
$12.50+
Garden Salad with Baby Shrimp 
Garden salad topped with baby shrimp.
$13.50+
Caesar Salad 
With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons.
$10.00+
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken 
With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, grilled chicken & croutons.
$13.00+
Cobb Salad 
Garden Salad topped with grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg.
$13.50+
Chef Salad 
Garden Salad topped with turkey, ham, American cheese, hard boiled egg.
$13.00+
Antipasto Salad 
Fresh garden salad with sliced Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni and american cheese.
$13.00+
Greek Salad 
With Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta cheese & black olives.
$12.50+
Southwestern Salad 
With Iceberg lettuce, croutons, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spicy chicken.
$13.00+

CALZONES

All served with 8oz marinara sauce.
Create Your Own Calzone 
$12.25+
Meat Lover's 
With sausage, meatball, pepperoni and ham.
$14.50+
Veggie Lover's 
With eggplant, spinach, olives and pepper.
$14.50+
Greek Lovers 
With Feta cheese, onions, & olives.
$14.25+
Southwestern 
Chicken cutlet with jalapenos and marinara sauce.
$14.50+
Chicken, Eggplant Parm 
$14.50+
Chicken Bacon Ranch 
$14.75+

STUFFED BREAD/ROLLS

12" made fresh to order from fresh dough, with 8oz marinara sauce
Buffalo Chicken 
comes with bleu cheese
$14.00
Crispy Chicken 
$13.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch 
$14.75
Broccoli 
$13.50
Broccoli & Sausage 
$14.00
Broccoli, Chicken, Spinach 
$14.75
Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon 
$14.75
Ham 
$13.50
Eggplant 
$13.75

COLD GRINDERS

All cold grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.
Turkey w/Bacon 
$12.00+
Turkey 
$11.50+
Tuna 
$11.00+
Ham 
$11.50+
Salami 
$12.00+
Italian Combo 
Genoa salami, ham and pepperoni served with Italian dressing.
$12.00+

HOT GRINDERS

All hot grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.
Steak & Cheese Grinder 
$11.00+
Hamburger Grinder 
$12.00+
Cheeseburger Grinder 
$12.50+
Bacon Cheeseburger Grinder 
$13.00+
Crispy Chicken Grinder 
$12.00+
Grilled Chicken Melt Grinder 
$12.50+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Grinder 
$13.00+

PARMIGIANA GRINDERS

Buffalo Chicken Sub 
$12.50+
Shrimp Sub 
$12.75+
Chicken Sub 
$12.00+
Meatball Sub 
$12.00+
Sausage Sub 
$12.00+
Sausage & Pepper Sub 
$12.00+
Sausage & Meatball Sub 
$12.50+
Eggplant Sub 
$12.00+
Chicken & Eggplant Sub 
$12.50+

BURGERS

1/2 lb burger served with lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Hamburger 
$8.00+
Cheeseburger 
$8.50+
Bacon Cheeseburger 
$9.00+
Crispy Chicken 
$8.00+
Grilled Chicken 
$8.00+
Fillet of Fish (1/2 lb.) 
$8.00+

QUESADILLAS & WRAPS

quesadillas served with ranch dressing quesadilla and wrap served with french fries
Grilled Chicken 
With lettuce, tomato, onion & cheese.
$10.00+
Grilled Chicken Caesar 
With romaine, lettuce, tomato, bleu cheese & cheese.
$10.00+
Buffalo Chicken 
With lettuce, tomato, onion, & cheese and bleu cheese on the side
$10.50+
Steak 
With lettuce, tomato, & cheese.
$10.00+
Philly Steak 
With onion, mushrooms, peppers & cheese.
$10.50+

BREADS

8 pieces each. Served with sauce.
Garlic Sticks 
$8.00
Cheese Sticks 
$9.50
Garlic Cheese Sticks 
$10.00

PARMIGIANA DINNERS

All pasta dishes are topped with mozzarella cheese & served with bread.
Chicken Parmigiana 
$16.50+
Meatball Parmigiana 
$15.50+
Sausage Parmigiana 
$15.50+
Eggplant Parmigiana 
$15.50+
Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana 
$16.75+
Chicken & Eggplant Parmigiana 
$16.75+
Chicken, Sausage, & Meatball Parmigiana 
$17.50+
Baked Ziti with Ricotta Cheese 
$14.00+
Baked Ziti with Chicken 
$17.00+
Baked Ziti with Meatball 
$16.00+
Baked Ziti with Sausage 
$16.00+
Baked Ziti with Eggplant 
$16.00+
Baked Ziti with Sausage & Meatball 
$17.00+
Baked Ziti with Chicken & Eggplant 
$17.00+
Baked Ziti with Chicken, Sausage, & Meatball 
$17.50+
Stuffed Shells 
$13.50+
Stuffed Shells with Ravioli 
$15.00+
Stuffed Shells with Meatball 
$15.50+
Stuffed Shells with Sausage 
$15.50+
Stuffed Shells with Sausage, Meatball, & Ravioli 
$16.00+

PASTA DINNERS

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti.
Marinara Sauce 
$13.00+
Marinara Sauce with Meatballs 
$15.00+
Marinara Sauce with Sausage 
$15.00+
Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Meatball 
$15.75+
Marinara Sauce with Chicken 
$16.00+
Marinara Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$16.50+
Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Broccoli 
$16.00+
Pink Marinara Sauce 
$13.00+
Pink Marinara Sauce with Meatballs 
$15.00+
Pink Marinara Sauce with Sausage 
$15.00+
Pink Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Meatball 
$15.75+
Alfredo Sauce 
$14.00+
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken 
$17.00+
Alfredo Sauce with Baby Shrimp 
$18.50+
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$18.00+
Alfredo Sauce with Shrimp & Broccoli 
$19.00+
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken & Bacon 
$18.50+
White Cream Sauce 
$13.50+
White Cream Sauce with Chicken 
$16.50+
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Bacon 
$17.50+
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$17.50+
White Cream Sauce with Ham, Bacon, Onion 
$16.00+
White Cream Sauce with Chicken, Mushrooms 
$17.50+
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$17.50+
White Cream Sauce with Sausage & Broccoli 
$16.50+
Alla Vodka Sauce 
$14.00+
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken 
$17.00+
Alla Vodka Sauce with Baby Shrimp 
$18.00+
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$18.00+
Alla Vodka Sauce with Baby Shrimp & Broccoli 
$18.75+
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken & Bacon 
$18.00+
Bolognese Sauce (Meat Sauce) 
$15.00+
Bolognese Sauce with Chicken 
$18.00+
Bolognese Sauce with Chicken & Bacon 
$15.50+
Bolognese Sauce with Sausage 
$17.00+
Bolognese Sauce with Meatball 
$17.00+
Bolognese Sauce with Bacon 
$18.00+
Bolognese Sauce with Sausage & Bacon 
$18.50+
White Wine Sauce with Chicken & Spinach 
$14.00+
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Mushrooms, Peas 
$15.00+
White Wine Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli 
$15.00+
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Sausage, Mushrooms 
$16.00+
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Sausage, Broccoli 
$16.00+
White Wine Sauce with Baby Shrimp & Broccoli 
$16.50+

CHICKEN DINNERS

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti.
Chicken Francese 
Chicken breast dipped in egg & sauteed in a lemon white wine sauce.
$15.50+
Chicken Marsala 
Chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms in a brown marsala wine sauce.
$15.50+
Chicken Florentine 
Chicken spinach & tomatoes sauteed in a white wine sauce.
$16.00+
Chicken Pizzaiola 
Chicken topped with sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, & mozzarella cheese.
$15.50+

SEAFOOD

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, angel hair or whole wheat spaghetti.
Jumbo Shrimp Francese 
Jumbo shrimp sauteed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
$17.00+
Jumbo Shrimp Marinara 
Jumbo shrimp over marinara sauce.
$16.50+
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi 
Jumbo shrimp sauteed with a lemon white wine sauce.
$17.00+
Jumbo Shrimp Fra Diavolo 
Jumbo shrimp over spicy marinara sauce.
$17.00+
Jumbo Shrimp Alla Supremo 
Jumbo shrimp & clams sauteed in a light marinara sauce.
$17.50+
Jumbo Shrimp Florentine 
Jumbo shrimp, spinach & tomatoes sauteed in a white wine sauce.
$17.50+
Jumbo Shrimp Florio 
Jumbo shrimp, mushrooms, peas & spinach sauteed with garlic & oil.
$17.50+
Clams Alla Supremo 
Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy white sauce.
$16.00+
Clam Sauce (Red) 
$13.50+
Clam Sauce (White) 
$13.50+

FRIED DOUGH

Fried Dough 
$9.95+

SIDES

Grilled Chicken 
$5.75+
Breaded Chicken 
$5.00+
Meatballs (4) 
$8.00
Meatballs (4) with Cheese 
$11.00
Sausage (3) 
$8.00
Sausage (3) with Cheese 
$11.00
Sauteed Spinach 
$7.00
Sauteed Vegetables 
$8.00

DESSERTS

Cheesecake 
$4.50
Cannoli 
$3.25
Chocolate Cake 
$4.75
Tartufo 
Ice cream dessert.
$5.95
Carrot Cake 
$4.95

COLD BEVERAGES

Gatorade 
Lemon Lime, Orange, Fruit Punch.
$2.25
Snapple 
Lemon, Peach, Mango, Fruit Punch, Kiwi Strawberry.
$2.25
Can Soda (12 oz.) 
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Iced Tea.
$1.50
Bottled Soda (20 oz.)  
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Pineapple Soda, Grape Soda.
$2.25
Bottled Water 
$1.25
2-Liter 
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Grape Soda, Fruit Punch, Iced Tea.
$3.50
Monster Energy Drink 
$2.95
Red Bull (8.4 oz.) 
$2.95
Homemade Iced Tea (24 oz.) 
$1.75
Mango Punch (24 oz.) 
$2.00
Homemade Lemonade 
$2.00

SMOOTHIES

Strawberry 
$4.25+
Strawberry Banana 
$4.75+
Pineapple 
$4.25+
Pineapple Banana 
$4.75+
Mango 
$4.25+
Tropical Rainbow 
$5.00+

ICE CREAM

Vanilla 
$3.00+
Chocolate 
$3.00+
Strawberry 
$3.00+
Cookies N Cream 
$3.00+

MILKSHAKES

Vanilla & Banana Milkshake 
$6.50
Vanilla Milkshake 
$4.50+
Chocolate Milkshake 
$4.50+
Strawberry Milkshake 
$4.50+
Strawberry & Banana Milkshake 
$5.00+
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.